Pizza was nice and crunchy great flavor a little oily but that's expected from a bar pie, but was amazing... service was amazing after being seated., We were served drinks quickly. Pizza came out pretty fast. We was a group of four and the bill was $65 which included one plain and one pepperoni pie, and a order of garlic bread, three soft drinks and one beer Pretty awesome Ambience was cool. They had booths, tables and bar, TVs clean bathroom. .. The only negative was I wish the garlic bread was a little bit better kind of just a small roll cut open with olive oil and garlic . Pizz

Star Tavern is known for their pizza for a reason, as it is delicious! This establishment has been around for a long time. Known for their thin-style pizza, you go into their small parking lot (and sometimes need to park further away from it at busy times) and look to get that open table. During peak times, it will be busy and inside may look small, but they are able to fit a good amount of people. This is a great place when you have a night out and are catching up with a group of friends! They do well in accommodating people and groups over the years and always had good service here. Their star of the show of course is the pizza! I've had many pizzas here over the years, with my favorite just being that classic cheese pie! If I go for toppings, I am a sausage or meatball type of guy. If you prefer a crisper pie (which I do!), you can ask for the pizza to be well-done. When I am leading the charge of ordering, this is my go-to! I enjoy hearing and experiencing that crisp on this pizza, which does have a good flavor! As for other food, I have not had anything bad here! I have gotten many of their appetizers depending on my friends and my moods such as Garlic Bread, Fried Calamari, Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Blossoms, and Mac & Cheese without any complaints!

Great food Long line but worth it had the burger and the burrito wrap and the egg sandwich

What can I say, Star is the best. Love the Pizza, wings, garlic bread, shrimp bowl. All delicious. There is a reason it is always busy. Wait staff is great, hectic pace and that makes this spot so much fun. Pizza is thin crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese...yummy

Classic NJ pizza place for tavern pies. Old school bar interior, really cool servers, and a healthy crowd. This place hardly warrants leaving a review but here i am. parking can quickly become a nightmare so plan to wait and be patient or try for street parking. their lot is small. for those with little kids they do have high chairs available but the dining room can get packed so take that into considerations. strollers are welcome but try and come during an offpeak time. again the dining area can get pretty packed. the booths have nice high backs so you dont have to worry about your nosey kid (like mine) peering at the next table over. some reviews say the cooks changed but they seemed the same to me! crispy crust and a little greasy (that's the flavor). pepperoni is 10/10 and our must get topping.

Visiting my brother in West Orange, he brought my son and I to what he claimed to be "the best pizza in the country" and I'd say his statement wasn't far off. The crust was thin, light and crisp, not overly sauced or topped. The crust and sauce were definitely the stars here and kitchen knows how to make them shine. My son got the ravioli Parmesan which he refused to share, so I can only imagine it was delightful. The dressing on their Caesar was homemade and bright, not over powering or over dressed. And I highly recommend the apple pie pizza. Dive in, the water is fine.

i have mixed feels about this place. First off, on a sunday early evening at like 430 it was slammed. service royally sucked. there isnt a host table, you just walk in and feel like you should seat yourself? we walked to the back window where the online orders were and no one helped us. make sure to speak up and then someone will tell u to seat yourself. we waited a few mins, no one came over to us, so we had to wave someone down. food came out before drinks. cheese pizza is good. im not a big fan of bar pies, but its good. let it sit for a few mins when it comes out. it was too floppy otherwise, so give it a second. but honestly it was filling and easy to share with 2 people. good flavor. wings. so we ordered buffalo wings with scampi sauce on them. we got just scampi wings? this isnt work. there was something off about them. i didnt hate them, but like i said something was off. also id like to state, there was no buffalo sauce on them at all. the wings have little meat on them and werent juicy. good prices, worth a trip to try it out.

One of the most famous pizza shops in NJ. Came here around 12PM on a Monday and there was a good amount of people but there was no wait. Very relaxed and chill ambiance. You can tell there were a lot of regulars there. The pizzas are thin and packed with flavor. My only complaint is that the pizzas didn't have the crispiness I was looking for in a bar pie. The mushroom pizza was a bit more watery than the plain but still good. Definitely recommend coming here to give it a try.